The Star of Bethlehem

The MagiFor centuries astronomers have speculated about the famous Star of Bethlehem, which the three Magi (the three wise men/the three kings) followed to the place of Christ’s birth.  Of course, the star may defy scientific explanation altogether, and be viewed as a miracle.  Nevertheless, various astronomical theories have been proposed, including that the star may have been a comet, or a supernova (an exploding star), or a “planetary conjunction” (a gathering of planets in one part of the sky).  In this column, we’ll examine two of today’s most popular theories, both of which hold that the planet Jupiter played a key role.

First, though, it’s useful to recall what the Bible says about the most famous star in history:

After Jesus was born in Bethlehem in Judea, during the time of King Herod, Magi from the east came to Jerusalem and asked, “Where is the one who has been born king of the Jews? We saw his star when it rose and have come to worship him.”

When King Herod heard this he was disturbed, and all Jerusalem with him. When he had called together all the people’s chief priests and teachers of the law, he asked them where the Messiah was to be born. “In Bethlehem in Judea,” they replied, “for this is what the prophet has written:

“‘But you, Bethlehem, in the land of Judah, are by no means least among the rulers of Judah; for out of you will come a ruler who will shepherd my people Israel.’”

Then Herod called the Magi secretly and found out from them the exact time the star had appeared. He sent them to Bethlehem and said, “Go and search carefully for the child. As soon as you find him, report to me, so that I too may go and worship him.”

After they had heard the king, they went on their way, and the star they had seen when it rose went ahead of them until it stopped over the place where the child was. When they saw the star, they were overjoyed. On coming to the house, they saw the child with his mother Mary, and they bowed down and worshiped him. Then they opened their treasures and presented him with gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh. And having been warned in a dream not to go back to Herod, they returned to their country by another route.

Matthew 2:1-12

Star of Bethlehem
Figure 1: “Adoration of the Magi” by Florentine painter Giotto di Bondone (1267–1337). The Star of Bethlehem is shown as a comet above the child. In all likelihood the Star of Bethlehem was not a comet as comets were viewed as omens of bad news (such as the deaths of kings) in the ancient world.

If you Google “Star of Bethlehem,” the Web site of a best selling DVD, The Star of Bethlehem, ranks at the very top.  The DVD features American attorney, Sunday school teacher, and amateur astronomer Rick Larson, who has conducted extensive research into the scientific, historical and theological aspects of the Star of Bethlehem.

After a careful review of scripture, Larson identifies nine characteristics of the star that, he believes, any scientific theory of the star must meet in order to be compliant with Christian belief.  For example, we can see from Matthew 2:1-12 that the star signified the birth of a king, that it was associated with the Jewish nation, and that, “it stopped over the place where the child was” – Bethlehem.

Larson then draws on his study of ancient history to address the all-important issue of the year that King Herod died.  According to Matthew 2, after the birth of Jesus, an angel appeared to Joseph in a dream, urging Joseph to flee Israel and take Mary and the infant Jesus to Egypt so as to avoid the wrath of Herod, who had issued orders that all male children in his realm under the age of two be executed.  Later in Matthew 2, an angel informs Joseph that Herod has died, and that it is safe to return to Israel.   So the argument goes that we should subtract two years from the year of Herod’s death to estimate the year Jesus was born.  Knowing Jesus’ estimated year of birth allows astronomers to run computer simulations of the positions of the stars and planets as they appeared in the night sky during the approximate time frame of Jesus’ birth.

Most historians and biblical scholars put Herod’s death at around the year 4 BC, meaning Jesus would have been born sometime around 6 BC.  But Larson points to recent historical research arguing that Herod died in 1 BC, which would place Jesus’ birth year around 3 BC.

Using modern astronomical software, Larson then runs computer simulations of the night sky over the Middle East in 3 and 2 BC and reaches two remarkable results – both involving the planet Jupiter.

Jupiter and Regulus
Figure 2: The planet Jupiter and the star Regulus in conjunction, mid-September, 3 BC.

Figure 2 shows part of the night sky from Jerusalem in mid-September of 3 BC.  Jupiter, known as the “King Planet” (from classical mythology) is in conjunction with (i.e., is close to) the star “Regulus,” known as the “King Star.”  Furthermore, Regulus is in the constellation (area of the night sky) “Leo,” which represents a lion, which was the symbol of Judah.

Furthermore, Larson notes, the planets in the night sky move relative to the ‘fixed’ stars: If you note the position of, say, Jupiter relative to stars such as Regulus from night to night, then you’ll note that Jupiter generally moves eastward across successive night skies.  However, occasionally, Jupiter will seemingly halt its eastward movement, and begin moving westward across successive night skies.  (This is an optical effect – called “retrograde motion” – resulting from the fact that Earth’s orbit around the sun lies within Jupiter’s orbit around the sun: See Figure 3.)  As Jupiter switches from moving eastward to moving westward (or vice versa), Jupiter appears to be stationary relative to the stars.  In this way, Jupiter appeared to stop “over the place where the child was,” as we read in Matthew 2.

Retrograde Motion
Figure 3: Retrograde motion of the planet Mars from October 13, 1978 to May 29, 1979. Relative to the stars in the background, Mars moves eastward from positions 1 to 5, stops at 5, then moves westward to 9, stops at 9, and then resumes its eastward movement to 14. Jupiter, Saturn and other planets outside Earth’s orbit demonstrate the same retrograde motion as we view those planets from Earth, which itself is in motion in its orbit about the sun.  Our planet’s orbital motion combined with the orbital motions of the outer planets cause the retrograde motion optical effect.

But, Larson argues, this conjunction of Leo with Regulus may have marked the conception of Jesus.  If we run the computer simulation of Jerusalem’s night sky forward nine months into June of 2 BC, we find that Jupiter and the planet Venus – two of the brightest planets in the night sky – come into extremely close conjunction, so much so that the two planets appear together as one, very bright ‘star’ in the night sky!

So the conjunction of Jupiter with Regulus in 3 BC, and/or the conjunction of Jupiter with Venus nine months later in 2 BC, may very well have been the star the Magi followed.


If we return to the Google search results for “Star of Bethlehem,” we find the Web site of professional astronomer Michael Molnar, who takes a different approach to the star of Bethlehem.  In his book, The Star of Bethlehem: The Legacy of the Magi, Molnar explores not only the Biblical account of the star, but also the point of view of the Magi, whom Molnar argues were astrologers/astronomers: In the ancient Roman world, astrology and astronomy were indistinguishable.  The Magi were held in high esteem in Roman culture, and were considered to be very knowledgeable, indeed, wise men.

Molnar, who does not believe in astrology, nevertheless has extensively researched the astrological beliefs prevalent in the Roman world.  He argues that modern astronomers who think about the Star of Bethlehem make a mistake by focusing on what spectacular displays may have appeared in the night sky around the time of Jesus’ birth, such as the appearance of a very bright star.  The focus on amazing heavenly displays is a bias of relatively modern astronomers, Molnar argues.  The Magi of ancient Rome, Molnar explains, were primarily concerned with the logic of their astrological system, which placed primary emphasis on the locations and arrangements of the planets in the night sky – the sequence of planets in the night sky, what constellations they were in, how far above the horizon they appeared at sunrise, etc.

So, for example, the fact that Jupiter and Venus were so close to one another that they appeared as one, very bright star would not necessarily be significant to the Magi.  Rather, the Magi would be much more interested in knowing whether Jupiter was to the east of Venus or to the west of Venus, the constellation(s) in which the two planets were located, and how high above the horizon the two planets appeared at sunrise.

Star Chart
Figure 4: A star chart showing the positions of Mercury, Mars, the Sun, Jupiter, the Moon, Saturn and Venus shortly after sunrise on April 17, 6 BC, as viewed from Jerusalem. The grey bar at the bottom represents the eastern horizon.   This particular arrangement of the planets, the Sun and the Moon, shortly after sunrise, in and around the constellation Aries, would have been very significant to the Magi, Molnar argues.

Accepting the consensus view of most scholars that Herod likely died in 4 BC, Molnar considers the positions of the planets in the night sky two years earlier – in 6 BC – and finds a particular arrangement of the planets Jupiter, Saturn, Venus, Mars and Mercury, together with the Moon and Sun, that would have been of great astrological significance to the Magi, indicating that a king was being born.  Furthermore, the centering of this particular planetary arrangement in and around the constellation Aries was significant, in part because in Roman-era astrology Aries was the sign of Judea.  So to the Magi, the arrangement of the stars and planets in 6 BC led them to believe that a great king was born in Judea.  Moreover, we should bear in mind Jupiter’s retrograde motion, as well as the spirit of revolution in the air at the time – the notion that a messiah would soon lead the Jewish people in revolt against the Roman Empire.  All of these factors combined, then, would naturally have induced the Magi to travel to Jerusalem – the capitol city of Judea – to inquire as to the whereabouts of the newborn king.


So whether we take the more Biblically-oriented analysis of Larson, or the more astrologically-oriented analysis of Molnar, we find compelling scenarios that support the notion that the Star of Bethlehem was a real, historical event.

0 thoughts on “The Star of Bethlehem”

  1. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://digg.com/@jimmy-kurtes
    ==
    though the nations parks, books and moreover stirring country towns are a significant fascination for ecotourists and those subsequently African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations enjoyable tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Hack No Surveys 2021
    【FREE IMVU HACK GENERATOR
    IMVU Credit Generator No Survey 2021
    IMVU Credit Hack No Surveys 2021
    Download File – IMVU FREE CREDITS 2021
    IMVU Credits Hack Download
    IMVU Credits Generator
    IMVU Generator No Surveys
    IMVU Free Credits

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  2. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://battlefy.com/imvu-free-credits-methods-2021-vip-membership-too
    ==
    even if the nations parks, books and moreover taking place country towns are a significant charm for ecotourists and those subsequently African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations standard tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Hack – Mod APK, Generator and Cheats
    How To Get Free Money On IMVU 2021
    IMVU Free Credits Hack
    IMVU Credits Hack – Free Credits LIVE PROOF IMVU Credits
    IMVU Generator No Surveys
    IMVU Hacks No Survey 2021
    IMVU CREDIT HACK WORKING
    IMVU Credit Hacker No Survey
    IMVU Credits Hack Download

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  3. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/624522673327953118
    ==
    though the nations parks, books and along with happening country towns are a significant draw for ecotourists and those afterward African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations adequate tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Credit Generator Online
    IMVU Generator 2021
    IMVU Credit Hack No Surveys 2021
    IMVU Credit Generator 2021
    【FREE IMVU HACK GENERATOR
    Download today new imvu credits hack
    IMVU Credit Hack No Surveys 2021
    Imvu Hack For Credits designs, themes, templates
    IMVU Credits Generator 2021

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  4. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://bigpicture.net/users/mark-kopes
    ==
    even though the nations parks, books and in addition to going on country towns are a significant pull for ecotourists and those subsequent to African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations conventional tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Hack Generate Unlimited Free Imvu Credits or Gems
    IMVU Hack No Human Verification 2021
    IMVU Vip Club Membership Promo 2021
    【FREE IMVU HACK GENERATOR
    IMVU Credit Generator
    Download today new imvu credits hack
    ヅ Imvu credits hack online no human verification
    IMVU Credits Hack 2021
    IMVU Free Credits

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  5. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://bigpicture.net/users/mark-kopes
    ==
    though the nations parks, books and as well as in the works country towns are a significant magnetism for ecotourists and those when African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations usual tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Credit Hack No Surveys
    FREE IMVU CREDIT (UNLIMITED)
    IMVU Hack 2021 – Online Cheat For 999k Credits
    【FREE IMVU HACK GENERATOR
    IMVU Hack 2021
    IMVU Hack Credits 2021
    IMVU hack credit – Home
    IMVU Credit Hack Quotes
    IMVU Credits Hack Download

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  6. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://bigpicture.net/users/mark-kopes
    ==
    even though the nations parks, books and next taking place country towns are a significant pull for ecotourists and those taking into consideration African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations tolerable tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    Free IMVU Badges
    IMVU Credits
    Imvu Hack For Credits designs, themes, templates
    IMVU Access Pass 2021
    IMVU Free Credits Hack 2021
    IMVU Hacks No Survey
    IMVU Link Generator
    IMVU Credits Hack 2021
    IMVU Access Pass

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  7. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://paiza.io/projects/Umm2QcPGIytuHv1IaTo3Qg
    ===========
    though the nations parks, books and then happening country towns are a significant fascination for ecotourists and those in the manner of African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations all right tropical climate and loosening.

    KW:
    IMVU Credit Hack Quotes
    IMVU Free Credits No Surveys 2021
    IMVU Credit Generator Online
    Snacks by IMVU Hack Unlimited Credits & Credits generator
    IMVU Credit Generator 2021
    IMVU Free Credits easy Imvu, Imvu cheats
    IMVU Hack – Mod APK, Generator and Cheats
    IMVU Hack Credit Generator
    Free IMVU Credits

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  8. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://paiza.io/projects/uFin-T4UP9-VIFlliAhmPg
    ===========
    even if the nations parks, books and also occurring country towns are a significant pull for ecotourists and those once African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations customary tropical climate and loosening.
    The Way of Choosing ClothesRunning is either a pleasure or a problemin the vocation.To begin with, it is a way of touristing.However, you have adifficult in adjusting to run in your holiday.If you want to wait for eveningto run, it is especially hard.You may feel so tired at that time and be eagerto have a hot bath or have a drink in the wineshop.It may have dangerous torun in the night because of unknowing condition of the road.Running in themorning is the best way to solve problem.For all this, you may always meetaccidental things.One of my best cheerful experiences of running is in theWeston Sue wares MEL of Englandin the night.My wife and I drive the car a day and I feel so tired.The hotelwhere we live is in the seaside.It is a huge Victorian architecture and towersstands everywhere.To make me happy is that there is two miles plank road withthe light shining.Before going out I wear the sport clothes.It is a warmevening and then the smell of sea flutters in the sky.Suddenly, I get recoveryand then begin running relax and unsurely.A Scottish set up a clinic in theWeston Sue wares MEL He is also taking exercise and we are running together fora while.
    KW:
    IMVU Hack 2021. Free Credits Generator Ultimate
    IMVU Credit Generator No Survey
    Imvu Mobile Hack
    IMVU Hack 2021 – Online Cheat For 999k Credits
    Free IMVU Credits
    IMVU Free Credits 2021
    IMVU Credits Generator 2021
    imvu free credits generator
    Download File – IMVU FREE CREDITS 2021

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  9. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/585327282819794328
    ===========
    even though the nations parks, books and plus happening country towns are a significant charm for ecotourists and those subsequent to African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations okay tropical climate and loosening.
    The Way of Choosing ClothesRunning is either a pleasure or a problemin the vocation.To begin with, it is a way of touristing.However, you have adifficult in adjusting to run in your holiday.If you want to wait for eveningto run, it is especially hard.You may feel so tired at that time and be eagerto have a hot bath or have a drink in the wineshop.It may have dangerous torun in the night because of unknowing condition of the road.Running in themorning is the best way to solve problem.For all this, you may always meetaccidental things.One of my best cheerful experiences of running is in theWeston Sue wares MEL of Englandin the night.My wife and I drive the car a day and I feel so tired.The hotelwhere we live is in the seaside.It is a huge Victorian architecture and towersstands everywhere.To make me happy is that there is two miles plank road withthe light shining.Before going out I wear the sport clothes.It is a warmevening and then the smell of sea flutters in the sky.Suddenly, I get recoveryand then begin running relax and unsurely.A Scottish set up a clinic in theWeston Sue wares MEL He is also taking exercise and we are running together fora while.
    KW:
    IMVU Generator 2021
    IMVU Hack Credit Generator
    IMVU Buy Credits
    imvu hack (@imvuhack1)
    IMVU Hack Credits
    How To Get Free Money On IMVU 2021
    IMVU Credits Hack No Surveys 2021
    IMVU Free Credits easy Imvu, Imvu cheats
    IMVU Hacks No Survey 2021

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  10. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/624522673327952419
    ===========
    even if the nations parks, books and after that in the works country towns are a significant charm for ecotourists and those past African lifestyle, for several site visitors it is actually the nations adequate tropical climate and loosening.
    The Way of Choosing ClothesRunning is either a pleasure or a problemin the vocation.To begin with, it is a way of touristing.However, you have adifficult in adjusting to run in your holiday.If you want to wait for eveningto run, it is especially hard.You may feel so tired at that time and be eagerto have a hot bath or have a drink in the wineshop.It may have dangerous torun in the night because of unknowing condition of the road.Running in themorning is the best way to solve problem.For all this, you may always meetaccidental things.One of my best cheerful experiences of running is in theWeston Sue wares MEL of Englandin the night.My wife and I drive the car a day and I feel so tired.The hotelwhere we live is in the seaside.It is a huge Victorian architecture and towersstands everywhere.To make me happy is that there is two miles plank road withthe light shining.Before going out I wear the sport clothes.It is a warmevening and then the smell of sea flutters in the sky.Suddenly, I get recoveryand then begin running relax and unsurely.A Scottish set up a clinic in theWeston Sue wares MEL He is also taking exercise and we are running together fora while.
    KW:
    IMVU Mod Apk V5.8.1 Download (Unlimited Credits, Money)
    IMVU Free Credits 2021
    IMVU Free Credits Hack 2021
    Free IMVU Credits Generator Hack No survey
    Imvu Mobile Hack
    IMVU Credits Generator Free IMVU Credits
    IMVU Credit Hacker No Survey 2021
    IMVU CREDIT HACK WORKING
    IMVU Credit Generator 2021

    Article sources:
    1. https://www.cdc.gov/mobile/mobileapp.html

  11. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://marekkornelsomnis.medium.com/

    ===========

    Belts are a indispensable supplement to combine your overall look. approachable in a wide array of fabrics and styles, belts provide endless opportunities to make public your fashion style. A bright assistant is the absolute pretension to grow fun to a simple pair of jeans.
    Use a leave-in conditioner if you have trouble past frizz. You desire to apply this product subsequent to a shower, past the hair dries. Don’t be afraid to put a large amount all more than your head, and create determined to object both the roots and the entirely tips of the hair.

    The player must battle Skynet enemies from the upcoming film as well as new enemies specifically designed for the game.Red Faction: GuerrillaIt is an upcoming third person shooter video game in development by Volition, Inc.and published by THQ.The game is set to be released June 2, 2009 for the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and Microsoft Windows platforms.The game is the third installment in the Red Faction series.In the gameplay of Red Faction: Guerrilla, the protagonist, Alec Mason, will be able to run, jump, hijack vehicles, and use weapons to traverse across the open world of Mars and fight the EDF Earth Defense Force.Weapons in the game will include: machine gun turrets, rocket turrets, remote charges, a sledgehammer, machine guns, and many others.PrototypePrototype is an upcoming sandbox style action game in development by Radical Entertainment and based on an original IP developed in house.The game is slated for release on June 9th, 2009 for the Xbox 360, Playstation 3 and Microsoft Windows.

    KW:
    How To Get Free IMVU Credits
    IMVU Hack Apk
    How To Get Free IMVU Credits 2021
    How To Hack IMVU Accounts
    IMVU Free Credits Hack
    IMVU Hack Account

  12. MixOneme says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    https://www.getrevue.co/profile/marekkornelsomnis

    ===========

    Belts are a critical auxiliary to enhance your overall look. welcoming in a wide array of fabrics and styles, belts pay for endless opportunities to proclaim your fashion style. A shiny belt is the perfect pretension to amass fun to a easy pair of jeans.
    Use a leave-in conditioner if you have trouble when frizz. You want to apply this product taking into consideration a shower, back the hair dries. Don’t be afraid to put a large amount all greater than your head, and make clear to goal both the roots and the enormously tips of the hair.

    The player must battle Skynet enemies from the upcoming film as well as new enemies specifically designed for the game.Red Faction: GuerrillaIt is an upcoming third person shooter video game in development by Volition, Inc.and published by THQ.The game is set to be released June 2, 2009 for the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and Microsoft Windows platforms.The game is the third installment in the Red Faction series.In the gameplay of Red Faction: Guerrilla, the protagonist, Alec Mason, will be able to run, jump, hijack vehicles, and use weapons to traverse across the open world of Mars and fight the EDF Earth Defense Force.Weapons in the game will include: machine gun turrets, rocket turrets, remote charges, a sledgehammer, machine guns, and many others.PrototypePrototype is an upcoming sandbox style action game in development by Radical Entertainment and based on an original IP developed in house.The game is slated for release on June 9th, 2009 for the Xbox 360, Playstation 3 and Microsoft Windows.

    KW:
    How To Hack IMVU Credits 2021
    Earn Free IMVU Credits
    IMVU Cards Codes 2021
    How To Get Free Credits On IMVU
    IMVU Cards Codes 2021
    IMVU Free Credits Hack

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *